Intel Core i5-8400 (B360) vs. AMD Ryzen 5 1600 (B350) > Gaming Tests, Let's Wait It Out

Gaming Tests, Allow'southward Wait Information technology Out

As noted earlier this is yet one of the few modern titles that does a expert chore of utilizing the Ryzen CPUs. It's not oftentimes you'll encounter results like these when looking at gaming performance and as AMD'south lucky would accept information technology, they just so happen to kick some serious silicon in the one game nobody really plays, hence the proper name Ashes of the Benchmark.

This is a more typical picture when comparing Ryzen and Coffee Lake CPUs in games, it'due south not a terrible picture but Intel is up to twenty% faster with a high-end GPU at 1080p. I'll discuss what this means later in the video. For now let'due south check out a few more than games.

From solar day one, Battlefield ane is a game that's played quite well with Ryzen CPUs and we run across that'south even so the case. Although notwithstanding slower than the Core i5-8400 the margins small plenty to deem insignificant, especially when looking at the all important 1% low data.

Far Cry 5 is also very playable with the Ryzen v 1600 despite the Core i5-8400 delivering superior performance. Overclocked the R5 1600 closes the gap but it's yet 7% slower than the 8400 on the B360 board for the ane% low result and 12% slower for the average frame rate.

I was expecting the Ryzen 5 1600 to stack up better in Overwatch and while you lot can't say over 160 fps at all times is bad, I was expecting the Core i5-8400 to pull away for the average frame charge per unit but run across a similar 1% low outcome. In any case both provided extremely smooth performance with the GTX 1080 Ti.

Finally we have Warhammer Vermintide 2 and this recently released championship does a good job of utilizing the Ryzen 5 1600. The Ryzen CPU was just 13% slower for the i% low effect and 4% slower for the average frame rate. Again both CPUs provided highly playable performance.

Conclusion

We've have a pretty skillful look at application and game performance. As expected Intel's faster in games for the almost part, while AMD's faster for most of the heavy workloads we tested, that existence the situation this is how I look at it. Even with a GTX 1080 Ti at just 1080p there's actually no telling which CPU you lot're using when gaming, both are exceptionally smooth and enable high frame rates, certainly high enough for the average gamer.

When information technology comes to things like extracting a compressed annal, you lot're absolutely going to notice a 60% reduction in fourth dimension. Even Blender where the overclocked Ryzen 5 1600 shaved 20% off the completion time, basically that means for a task that takes the Intel CPU an hour and six minutes, you lot're looking at 53 minutes with the Ryzen CPU, giving you a 13 infinitesimal head showtime to move onto the next job and over the course of a twenty-four hour period that really adds upward.

Of course, the time saving could be fifty-fifty larger than that, we saw Ryzen shave 30% off Intel's render time in Corona. Or it could also be less: we saw a sixteen% reduction with Premiere Pro and so virtually cypher with HandBrake. That interruption-even situation appeared to be a worst instance scenario for AMD. Nosotros also saw when overclocked Ryzen only matched the Warp Stabilization performance of the Core i5-8400 in Premiere.

What this shows is that for heavy workloads the Ryzen 5 1600 is king and this is something anybody will do good from regardless of hardware configuration. Meanwhile to savour the Core i5'southward superior gaming performance yous will require an extreme graphics card. With a GTX 1070 or less the divergence won't exist seen on the frame charge per unit counter. Which CPU volition offer the all-time feel in two-iii years time is anyone's guess, I wouldn't dare waste matter your time speculating about such a thing.

What I will do is break down the pricing to work out which platform offers yous the almost bang for your cadet. Start with the retentivity the cost difference between DDR4-2666 and 3200 is negligible, most of the time you're not paying a premium for the higher clocked memory.

And so B360 and B350 motherboards of similar quality cost around the aforementioned amount, I'd wait to pay around $80 for a quality board. Then with both CPUs costing around the same corporeality buyers are looking at spending effectually $430 for either combo with 16GB's of DDR4 retentivity. If you want to pair the Core i5-8400 with a Z370 board which honestly I recommend doing, and so it's going to cost around $forty more, making Intel'due south platform nine% more than expensive.

The reason I wouldn't bother with B360 or H370 boards is the lack of features and support for overclocking. Although you lot can't overclock the Core i5-8400 a Z370 lath gives you more options in the future, it'll too fetch a amend toll on the second mitt market. In any instance equally it stands you can secure the 8400 with motherboard and retentivity for the same price as the Ryzen v 1600 on a B350 lath, and so pricing has been somewhat neutralized.

This leaves AMD and Intel in a bit of a stalemate, they both have their strengths and weaknesses but overall are very evenly matched. I can't imagine yous'd exist anything but impressed with either solution. That said I'd probably purchase the Ryzen 5 1600 for the simple fact that I spend more fourth dimension working on my PC than I do playing. I besides similar the idea that AMD'southward promising future compatibility with new Ryzen CPUs. Intel, on the other hand, volition likely ditch their current mainstream platform later the adjacent processor release.

All that said, correct now I'd concord off buying either a Ryzen or Coffee Lake CPU until the 2nd-gen Ryzen serial arrives later this month. At which point yous'll then accept access to what will probably be slightly faster 2nd-gen Ryzen CPUs and fifty-fifty cheaper 1st-gen Ryzen CPUs. What today'south tests show us is that if AMD can find another 10% performance with second-gen Ryzen then they're going to exist in great shape.

Shopping Shortcuts: